Thursday, 30 October 2008

christian voice:

The best and truly Christian voice I heard amidst the cacophony of blame game and wounded hearts was of a reputed Christian scholar P N Benjamin, in Bengaluru. He wrote, 'The real source of danger to the Indian Christian community is not the handful of Hindu extremists. Most of the violent incidents have been due to aggressive evangelising. Other than this, there have been few attacks on Christians. Finally, the sensitive and sensible Christians must realise that acts of certain groups of Christian evangelists are the root-cause of tension between Christians and Hindus. Christian leaders should come out in the open to disown such acts of intolerance. The best and perhaps the only way Christians can bear witness to their faith, is by extending their unconditional love to their neighbours and expecting nothing in return.'
And he advised, 'Will the Christians listen to the words of sanity of Dr Ken Gnanakan, well-known Christian scholar who told this writer the other day: 'Preach Christ, but do not condemn others'. Even Jesus said in John 3.17: 'God did not send his Son to condemn the world�'
Hindus are like that. The aggressive conversions and the justification of it by the 'harvesters' are hurting Hindus as much as any other violence. Still there are saner ways to explain that hurt if there are saner platforms to receive those voices.
Have you seen in any magazine or periodical a story about the swami who was brutally murdered on the night of Krishna's birthday in Orissa? Why was he killed? They keep blaming the Maoists, and have immediately denied their hand through a well-publicised statement. And the aged lady monk, Ma Bhaktimoyee? Should her murder while performing puja be ignored just because she was not a nun and the Vatican won't speak about her plight and Italy's [Images] blind-curtained state would not call the Indian ambassador to protest over her death? How long do we have to run our public life directed by signals from firang-lands?article by tarun vijay in rediffmail

concern:

Attacks on one community by another should be a cause of concern to any Indian interested in the unity, prosperity and strength of this nation. There is a disturbing denial mode in sections of both the Muslim and the Hindu communities.
Sections of the Muslim community are not prepared to accept that their co-religionists are behind this wave of jihadi terrorism. An attempt is being made by these sections, supported by sections of the so-called secular community, either to deny the involvement of some Muslims in jihadi terrorism or to rationalise their involvement through various arguments. There is a simultaneous attempt to denigrate and demonise the police and other law-enforcing agencies by debunking their version of the terrorist strikes and by coming in the way of their investigation.
Sections of the Hindu community owing allegiance to the so-called Hindutva groups are not prepared to accept any blame on their community and tend to project the anti-Christian violence as an outcome of spontaneous tribal anger against Christian missionaries with which, according to them, the Hindutva organisations have nothing to do. The perceived inaction of the law-enforcing agencies in the face of the anti-Christian violence is sought to be rationalised and explained through various arguments such as the lack of road and other means of communications in the affected areas which rendered prompt police action difficult.

While dealing terror.......

Dealing terror:People should have faith in the system and try and rectify problems in a democratic manner. We have to moderate the system. It is very important to educate the Muslims .. We need to moderate their views too.

Friday, 17 October 2008

anti conversion law.

Why should not there be a sustained and sincere all religion debate in india on an anti conversion law?
  • Lt.col.a.s..amarasekara, a srilankan bhuddist activist has expressed the following fear.
  • While everyone is focussing their minds on the Ltte problem, we sincalese buddhists are pitted against another force as dangerous. The dangers that the sinhalese buddist way of life will have to face due to conversions in the near future.What happened in south korea , wher the 80 %buddist population was reduced to 18% in in 5 decades will be repeated here. I t is proved beyond doubt that world vision,an american funded christian evangelical organisation, was surrepticiouslytrying to cinvert sinhalese buddist into christianity.

cpi[m] complaints against church:

  • Tripura is one of the indian states where ,as the cpi[m] chief minister Manik Sarkar has himself acknowledged the foreign funded baptist church supports subversive activities ,including the conversion of tribals.
  • The church backed the seperatist outfit ,national liberation front of tripura,gunned down 16 hindus at a market place in west tripura district on 13 january,2002.,on the eve of makar sankranthi,a serious incident largely uncovered by national media.

conversion

Conversion-resentment in assam against world vision's flood relief operations in Majuli,largest river island in brahmaputhra and a sacred seat of sankara deva,the great reformist saint.

Tuesday, 14 October 2008

conversion of people from one faith to another

Conversion..problem and solution?Has the time come for the Government to set up a National Commission to investigate religious conversions in India? Certainly. Let the Nation know how many conversions have taken place from—and into—Hinduism, Islam, Christianity, Sikhism and other faiths since 1947. Let the commission throw light on the districts where, and how, significant changes in religious demography have taken place, and whether conversions have created resentment and social disharmony in their wake.
An unbiased commission would reveal three irrefutable facts: (1) Christianity accounts for the largest number of
converts; (2) Christian organisations conduct service activities—schools, hospitals, poverty-alleviation programmes, relief during calamities, etc.—with exemplary dedication and professionalism. However, some of them, though not all, make the conversion agenda a part of their seva agenda; (3) Foreign funds supporting these charitable activities have greatly aided conversions.
Take, for example, the following information, pertaining to the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act (FCRA), available on the website of the Union Home Ministry. During 2005-06, Rs 7,877 crore was received by way of foreign donations to various NGOs, up from Rs 5,105 crore in 2003-04. Tamil Nadu (Rs 1,610 crore) and Andhra Pradesh (Rs 1,011 crore) were among the highest recipients. The highest foreign donors were Gospel Fellowship Trust USA (Rs 229 crore), Gospel for Asia (Rs 137 crore), Foundation Vincent E Ferrer, Spain (Rs 104.23 crores) and Christian Aid, UK (Rs 80.16 crores). The largest recipients were World Vision (Rs 256 crore), Caritas India (Rs 193 crore), Rural Development Trust Andhra Pradesh (Rs 127 crore), Churches Auxiliary for Social Action (Rs. 95.88 crores) and Gospel For Asia (Rs. 58.29 crore). The funds received by some of these organisations have trebled or quadrupled in just three years since the formation of the UPA Government.
BJP expects to win 4/515 Oct, 2008, 0311 hrs IST,Devesh Kumar, ET Bureau

NEW DELHI: For the BJP, outcome of the elections to the five state assemblies will be a crucial pointer to its ability to wrest power at the Centre i
n the biggest electoral battle to follow. If it fares well in the state polls, along with its alliance partners, it will be sufficiently charged up to take the battle into the UPA camp. The saffron party’s path, however, has several roadblocks. It is in power in Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Delhi. Conventional wisdom has it that, barring a few exceptions, parties in power have been hamstrung with anti-incumbency. The burden of soaring expectations of people prove too much for ruling parties to meet, and so will it be for BJP. It will difficult for the party, critics say, to buck the trend. The saffron party, however, is confident of continuing with its winning streak. BJP poll strategists argue that a combination of factors, including a ‘good governance,’ ‘disarray’ in the Congress camp, terrorism, inflation and a high interest-rate regime, will help BJP beat the anti-incumbency disadvantage in the three states where it has been in power, while facilitating its task of wresting power from the Congress in Delhi after 10 years. Surveys commissioned by the party in Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh show that while the chief ministers enjoy high ratings, there was widespread discontent against performances of quite a few ministers and MLAs. The BJP leadership, therefore, has decided to go in for a major surgery by replacing almost of half of its legislative contingent in each of these states. The exercise had worked wonders for the party’s prospects in Gujarat, where as many as 49 of the 127 MLAs were replaced, and the saffron brass is hoping that the formula will be effective again. While the leadership issue in all the states has been settled, the party appears to be acting in synergy with other members of the Sangh Parivar. The cadre, the BJP brass feels, is sufficiently motivated to work for the party’s victory in each of these states. Besides assuming a popular discontent against the Congress-led UPA government at the Centre over issues such as price-rise, ‘spurt in terror attacks’ across the country, farmers’ suicides and high interest rates, the saffron leadership is hoping that the growing profile of the BSP in Delhi, Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Chhattisgarh will eventually end up damaging the Congress. The electoral battle in Rajasthan, which was the epicentre of violent Gurjar protests early this year, will test the effectiveness of the caste coalition built by the party. The Gurjars, who comprise some five per cent of the electorate, may give jitters to the leadership. In neighbouring Madhya Pradesh, besides battling constituency-level anti-incumbencies, the BJP will have to factor in the upshot of former chief minister Uma Bharati’s desertion. A backward Lodh, the fiery leader wields pockets on influence in the Bundelkhand region. The return of former chief minister Ajit Jogi to the political stage in Chhattisgarh may upset the BJP’s applecart. The Congress leader is known for his guile and craftiness — factors which can work both ways for the BJP. The party’s decision to name Mr Vijay Kumar Malhotra as chief ministerial candidate for Delhi has not gone down well with a section of the BJP who contend that he does not have the stature and the image to match chief minister Sheila Dikshit.

Sunday, 5 October 2008

Nepal III - Which model will Prachanda and his Maoists follow ?

Which model will Prachanda and his Maoists follow? Will it be the Chinese, the Cuban or the Vietnamese model? If one goes by his past statements and interviews, he is likely to follow a mix of the Chinese and Cuban models, and not the Vietnamese. He has always been attracted by the idea of Nepal serving as a rear base for exporting Maoist revolution to India. He also believes that a destabilised India preoccupied with internal security as being in the long-term interests of Nepal. We should not allow his present charm offensive towards India make us forget his past.
Till now, our military planners have been worried over the dangers of India being confronted one day with a two-front war -- with Pakistan and China. We now have to think seriously about the dangers of a three-front war with Pakistan, China and Nepal.
Once Communists come to power -- through an armed revolution or through the ballot box -- they try to see that nobody can dislodge them. There have been exceptions, of course. Nicaragua, for example. But, there the Communists were prevented from entrenching themselves through strong US support for non-Communist elements.
It is neither in the interests of Nepal nor of India for the Maoists to entrench themselves in power and convert the RNA into the PLA of Nepal and turn Nepal into a rear base to help the Maoists in India. The plans of the Maoists for a presidential form of Government in Nepal with all powers concentrated in the hands of Prachanda and with the RNA replaced by the PLA should be thwarted.
All genuinely democratic forces in Nepal and the military leadership should join hands to prevent the Communists from carrying out their long-term designs. The Communists will fight back ferociously all attempts to deny them the fruits of power. The fear of a possibly bloody riposte by the Communists should not deter those worried over the implications of the Maoists' plan from acting before it is too late.
Maoists led by Prachanda coming to power, and sticking to it, is in the interest of neither Nepal nor India. Sooner or later, they will export their 'revolution' to India. This must be prevented at all cost: If it means an Army takeover of Nepal, so be it
B Raman, The Pioneer, 29/04/2008

Nepal - II

Communists way of capturing power in China, Korea, Vietnam and Cuba
After Mao Tse-tung's PLA captured power in China in 1949 and proclaimed the People's Republic of China, the PLA became the Army of the state. The leaders of the Chinese Communist Party proclaimed China as the "rear base" for all Communist movements in Asia. It assisted North Korea in its war with the US-led coalition, North Vietnam in its war initially against the French and subsequently against the Americans and the South Vietnamese Army, and the Communist insurgencies in Malaysia, northern Thailand and Myanmar, and helped the Indonesian Communists in a big way till the military coup staged by the Indonesian Army under President Suharto saved the country from falling into the hands of the Communists.
The Burmese Army under Gen Ne Win similarly captured power in the early-1960s to prevent that country from falling into the hands of the Communists and other ethnic insurgent groups. In 1979, after 30 years of trying to export Maoism, Deng Xiaoping changed this policy and stopped exporting 'revolution' to other countries.
After capturing power in Cuba in the early-1960s, Mr Fidel Castro converted his armed guerrillas into the Army of the state and embarked on a policy of exporting the Cuban revolution to other Latin American countries, with Cuba serving as the rear base. The death of Che Guavera, who was asked to have this policy executed, allegedly at the hands of the Central Intelligence Agency, put an end to Cuba's Communist dreams in Latin America, but till today, the Cuban Government and Communist Party continue with their attempts at political subversion in the Latin American countries.
Only Vietnam proved a refreshing contrast. After they defeated the Americans and the South Vietnamese Army in 1975 and re-united their country, they concentrated on development at home and avoided all ideological adventures abroad.
B Raman, The Pioneer, 29/04/2008

Nepal - I

The priorities of Prachanda, the Nepalese Maoist Leader
Ultimately, we will have to fight with the Indian Army. That is the situation. Therefore, we have to take into account the Indian Army. When the Indian Army comes in with thousands and thousands of soldiers, it will be a very big thing. But we are not afraid of the Indian Army because, in one way, it will be a very good thing. They will give us lots of guns. And lots of people will fight them. This will be a national war. And it will be a very big thing. They will have many difficulties intervening. It will not be so easy for them. But if they stupidly dare... they will dare, they will be compelled. They will do that stupidity. We have to prepare for that. And for that reason we are saying we will also need a particular international situation. And for us this has to do mainly with India, Indian expansionism. When there is an unstable situation in India and a strong mass base there in support of People's War in Nepal and there are contradictions within the Indian ruling class -- at that point we can seize, we can establish and declare that we have base areas, that we have a Government."
-- Prachanda, the Nepalese Maoist leader, in an interview to a Latin American journalist
In his statements and interviews before the election, Prachanda has given clear indications of his priorities if the Maoists came to power. First, abolish the monarchy and proclaim Nepal as a republic with a presidential form of Government. Second, himself assume office as the President of Nepal. Third, abrogate all existing agreements with India and re-negotiate those of them, which are considered to be in Nepal's interests. Finally, merge the armed cadre of the Maoists into the RNA to convert a royalist Army into a people's Army.
Maoists led by Prachanda coming to power, and sticking to it, is in the interest of neither Nepal nor India. Sooner or later, they will export their 'revolution' to India. This must be prevented at all cost: If it means an Army takeover of Nepal, so be it
B Raman, The Pioneer, 29/04/2008

Nepal - I

The priorities of Prachanda, the Nepalese Maoist Leader
Ultimately, we will have to fight with the Indian Army. That is the situation. Therefore, we have to take into account the Indian Army. When the Indian Army comes in with thousands and thousands of soldiers, it will be a very big thing. But we are not afraid of the Indian Army because, in one way, it will be a very good thing. They will give us lots of guns. And lots of people will fight them. This will be a national war. And it will be a very big thing. They will have many difficulties intervening. It will not be so easy for them. But if they stupidly dare... they will dare, they will be compelled. They will do that stupidity. We have to prepare for that. And for that reason we are saying we will also need a particular international situation. And for us this has to do mainly with India, Indian expansionism. When there is an unstable situation in India and a strong mass base there in support of People's War in Nepal and there are contradictions within the Indian ruling class -- at that point we can seize, we can establish and declare that we have base areas, that we have a Government."
-- Prachanda, the Nepalese Maoist leader, in an interview to a Latin American journalist
In his statements and interviews before the election, Prachanda has given clear indications of his priorities if the Maoists came to power. First, abolish the monarchy and proclaim Nepal as a republic with a presidential form of Government. Second, himself assume office as the President of Nepal. Third, abrogate all existing agreements with India and re-negotiate those of them, which are considered to be in Nepal's interests. Finally, merge the armed cadre of the Maoists into the RNA to convert a royalist Army into a people's Army.
Maoists led by Prachanda coming to power, and sticking to it, is in the interest of neither Nepal nor India. Sooner or later, they will export their 'revolution' to India. This must be prevented at all cost: If it means an Army takeover of Nepal, so be it
B Raman, The Pioneer, 29/04/2008

If you give computers to young children, they start to believe that you don’t have to think, all you have to do is search’

Edward de Bono, Thought Guru
‘If you give computers to young children, they start to believe that you don’t have to think, all you have to do is search’
• Dr. de Bono has made people not only think about how they think, but also use new ways of looking at things to invent products, find solutions to persistent problems, and resolve conflict.
• Today people talk about big problems in our climate. What I'm talking about is a much bigger problem, which is the poor state of world thinking: that our thinking: We have essentially done nothing about thinking outside mathematics for 2,400 years, since the gang of three -- the Greek gang of three (Socrates, Aristotle, Plato) -- designed 'software' for thinking, which we've used ever since.
• Perception is by far the most important factor in thinking, 90 per cent of the errors are errors of perception, not of logic. And if your perception is wrong . . . your logic can be erroneous.
• The Prophet Muhammad had more to say about thinking than any other religious leader.
• 'One hour of thinking is better than 70 years of praying.' He says, 'The ink of a scholar is more holy than the blood of a martyr.' He says, 'One learned man gives more trouble to the Devil than a thousand worshippers.'
• The people with the greatest power to change are 17-year-old girls. Because all the men up to the age of 28 are bound to try to impress them.
• Six Thinking Hats separate put the thinking precess:-
Under the white hat, everyone is looking for facts, information, what we have, what we need, what questions have we asked, how do we get the information. Red hat: permission to put forward your emotions, your intuition, without having to justify or explain it. Black hat is critical: what is wrong, the risks, the downside, why it may not work. The yellow hat: values, benefits. The green hat: creative, new ideas, possibilities, alternatives and so on. The blue hat is the organizing hat: summary, outcome.
• The point I make is: design rather than judgment. For example, in the Israel-Palestine situation. Here we have two of the most intelligent groups on the earth, and for 60 years, they've been fighting each other. Palestinians know that Israel is not going to disappear; Israelis know Palestine is not going to disappear. So we need to design a way forward. Just a suggestion: you let them vote in each other's elections; let them have half a vote each. So the Israelis will never elect Hamas, the Palestinians will never elect Sharon. They'll end up voting constructive leaders who will design a way forward. And that's design. Instead of saying, 'You're bad and if you don't stop doing this we're going to bomb you.'
Indian Express, Walk The Talk coloumn

‘HOW THE BJP’S LEADERSHIP DIFFERS FROM THAT OF THE CONGRESS’

Leadership is an integral and a very important aspect of the character of a political party.
1 Democratic Party VS. Dynastic Party
The first major difference between our two organizations is this: the BJP is a democratic party and the Congress is a dynastic party.
2 Leadership culture in the BJP
Dr. Syama Prasad Mookerjee, who in 1951 founded the Bharatiya Jana Sangh. He was an eminent freedom fighter, he was a distinguished educationist, one who became the Vice Chancellor of Calcutta University at the age of 33 – indeed, the youngest ever vice-chancellor in the history of the Prestigious University.
Dr. Mookerjee was minister in the first government established after Independence under Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru’s premiership.
Dr Mookerjee resigned from Nehru’s Cabinet in protest against the Prime Minister’s unprincipled and uncaring attitude towards the Hindus in East Pakistan. He later became a martyr in Srinagar for the cause of the full integration of Jammu and Kashmir into the Indian Union.
The second, great leader from BJP a self-made personality Pandit Deendayal Upadhyaya, who was the chief ideologue, organizer and guide of the Jana Sangh, was born in a very poor family. But he was a giant in intellect and idealism.
The third towering leader of the party one who both led the Jana Sangh and later became the founder president of the BJP in 1980 – is Atal Bihari Vajpayee.
3 Deliberate devaluation of the office of the Prime Minister
P V Narasimha Rao and dr. Manmohan Singh, a conscious and sustained attempt has been made to emphasise that real power resides not at 7 Race Course Road but at 10 Janpath. This has become especially pronounced in the case of Dr Singh.
4 Dr. Singh’s ‘ contract’ not with people, but with one individual
I am sorry to say that Dr. Manmohan Singh’s majboori is worse. Instead of a contract with the people of India, the Prime Minister had a contract with just one individual, who is described by many people as the Super Prime Minister’.
5 Contrasting approaches to coalition management
At one point, we had as many as two-dozen parties in the National Democratic Alliance. The BJP was the largest party in the alliance. Nevertheless, we scrupulously followed the ‘Coalition Dharma’.
Here is a government that is singularly lacking in both cohesion and vision. The UPA is nothing but an opportunistic alliance to keep the BJP out of power by raising the bogey of ‘secularism.’
6 Congress leadership is compromising national security
The Vajpayee government conducted Pokharan I in order to strengthen India’s national security.
In contrast, the government of Sonia Gandhi and Dr. Manmohan Singh wants to sign the Indo-US nuclear deal, which, in the name of enhancing our energy security, will actually weaken India’s national security and undermine our strategic autonomy.
L. K. Advani, In India Today Leadership conclave, March 2008

Price Rise And Inflation

Precarious Situation
• The economy is moving towards a dangerous situation. The price index and inflation rate are shooting up and the share market has shown a great decline. All this is the result of wrong decisions and advice by bureaucrats. It is surprising that to reduce the price index, the government is importing essential goods without sparing a thought for the Indian farmers. A day will come when the nation will have to bow before other nations for food. Food and shelter cannot be substituted by industrialisation and share markets. K. Ravi, Vaikom
• Food shortage was anticipated long ago. Agriculture scientists demanded and increase in production through improvised and innovative methods and offered suggestions for the same. The government did not pay farmers reasonably but resorted to imports at a higher cost. This has resulted in the depletion of foreign exchange. The goal should have been to achieve self sufficiency in food production. A. Ramanathan, Chennai
• The UPA government is not just going to leave the voter angry in 2009 - It is going to leave behind chronic inflation. Although inflation affects all the classes, the poor are the worst hit. Not only will their incomes fall but their sources of income will disappear. India's robust growth rate has been able to cushion the adverse effects of inflation to a limited extent. Despite projections of exponential growth in yields of oil seeds and pulses, there has been no action to marry the laboratory to the farm and actualise theses. J.S. Acharya, Hyderabad (Letters to the Editor Coloumn, The Hindu, April 1, 2008)
Rising Inflation, Growing Unrest
The production of cereals, especially wheat, pulses and oil seeds, has been going down over the last several years. This is the real cause of discontent among the masses.
• The current crisis is a clash between declining supplies of goods and their increasing demand by the people. This paradox of reducing supplies and rising demand is accentuated by the recently introduced commodity exchanges whose thrust is forward trading. If it chooses, the Government can intervene through the exchanges by selling commodities forwards and delivering them through imports.
• Alternatively, import the items and flood the markets with their supplies. Oversupply is the key to deflating prices. Apart from the consumption, getting as much as he requires, over supply also demoralises the speculative trader or the hoarder. In the medium term, the answer must lie in inducing greater production. Prafull Goradia, Pioneer, 3.4.2006

Major Victory for Shiksha Bachao Andolan Samiti

NCERT ordered to remove all 75 objectionable passages from textbooks
• The Shiksha Bachao Andolan Samiti, which has been fighting from streets to the courts against distortion of history by the UPA government, achieved a major success on January 30 when a division bench of Delhi High Court headed by Justice T.S. Thakur, ordered the National Council of Education Research and Training (NCERT) to remove all 75 objectionable paragraphs in its history books before the next academic session.
• The NCERT had earlier informed the court that it would remove objectionable passages, including references to Sikh religious leader Guru Gobind Singh, scientist Aryabhatt, Mughal Emperor Akbar, and describing author Bankim Chandra Chatterjee and freedom fighters Bal Gangadhar Tilak and Lala Lajpat Rai as militants, from its books.
• Some of these passages in our prima facie opinion pass sweeping remarks against some of the recognized and well respected leaders of this country.. Similar sweeping statements are there regarding some of the communities like 'Jat" Chief Justice M.K. Sharma and Justice Hima Kohli had then said.
• Talking to Organiser Shri Dina Nath Batra, convener of Shiksha Bachao Andolan Samiti said they won only one battle and three more battles are still to be won. He said the second battle to be won is against the Hindi textbooks, which are replete with more poisonous text than that in the history books. "The hearing on our PIL against the Hindi books is going on in the court and the court has to deliver its verdict soon. Our third battle is against sex education and fourth battle is against Delhi University, which is teaching highly distorted history to college students. We have launched a signature campaign against it in Delhi University and soon we are going to start an indefinite dharna."
Organiser Weekly
March 2, 2008

Major Victory for Shiksha Bachao Andolan Samiti

NCERT ordered to remove all 75 objectionable passages from textbooks
• The Shiksha Bachao Andolan Samiti, which has been fighting from streets to the courts against distortion of history by the UPA government, achieved a major success on January 30 when a division bench of Delhi High Court headed by Justice T.S. Thakur, ordered the National Council of Education Research and Training (NCERT) to remove all 75 objectionable paragraphs in its history books before the next academic session.
• The NCERT had earlier informed the court that it would remove objectionable passages, including references to Sikh religious leader Guru Gobind Singh, scientist Aryabhatt, Mughal Emperor Akbar, and describing author Bankim Chandra Chatterjee and freedom fighters Bal Gangadhar Tilak and Lala Lajpat Rai as militants, from its books.
• Some of these passages in our prima facie opinion pass sweeping remarks against some of the recognized and well respected leaders of this country.. Similar sweeping statements are there regarding some of the communities like 'Jat" Chief Justice M.K. Sharma and Justice Hima Kohli had then said.
• Talking to Organiser Shri Dina Nath Batra, convener of Shiksha Bachao Andolan Samiti said they won only one battle and three more battles are still to be won. He said the second battle to be won is against the Hindi textbooks, which are replete with more poisonous text than that in the history books. "The hearing on our PIL against the Hindi books is going on in the court and the court has to deliver its verdict soon. Our third battle is against sex education and fourth battle is against Delhi University, which is teaching highly distorted history to college students. We have launched a signature campaign against it in Delhi University and soon we are going to start an indefinite dharna."
Organiser Weekly
March 2, 2008

RAM SETHU-III

UPA's draft affidavit wants SC to decide on Ram Sethu
U-Turn: 'ASI can neither support nor contradict scientific conclusion, natural formation can be called monument'
• Singed by the political firestorm over its last affidavit on Ram Sethu in which it questioned Ram's existence, the UPA Government plans to pass the buck to the Supreme Court and take a dramatically different tack, as per its draft affidavit scheduled to be submitted to the Supreme Court early next month.
• The affidavit of the Archaeological Survey of India and the Culture Ministry - that came up before the Cabinet Committee on Political Affairs today has cited scientific studies reinforcing the Government's earlier stand that the structure isn't man made but has gone on to say that the ASI doesn't have the expertise "either to support or contradict this conclusion. "It is thus prayed, "the affidavit concludes, "that the Court may pass appropriate orders/ directions to all concerned which it may deem fit in larger interest of the society."

Chinese Incursions Inside Arunachal Pradesh

(Part III)
1. Similarly, to deal with China, to counter Pakistan's proxy war, the country must sustain a policy for 20-30 years. And for that, you have to keep readers and viewers focused on that issue for decades at a time. But the media is fixated only on what it can project as 'breaking news' in this shift – what was 'breaking news' in the last shift is 'old hat' by this one.
2. This weak-kneed government is a problem, of course: its nominal leaders have lifted helplessness to new heights. But the even graver problem now is that the one instrument, by which it could be shaken up, the media, has become a problem of its own.
3. Make no mistake: China watches all this. It watches the feeble, confused, contradictory ways in which our government, and even more our society, reacts each time it advances a claim. And it pursues its policy:
Claim;
Repeat the claim;
Go on repeating the claim
Grab;
Hold;
Let time pass.
And they will reconcile themselves to the new situation. Has the policy not succeeded in regard to Tibet? No Indian Prime Minister will dare mention the word Tibet or Taiwan' – lest doing so offends China. But China will go on claiming what it wants – for reasons that we must understand.
4. But why think of Tibet and Taiwan? Has the six-step policy not succeeded in regard to Aksai Chin? In spite of the unanimous resolution that the Parliament passed at the time under Panditji, is there an Indian leader who will today demand that China hand back Aksai Chin? And do you think that when they deliberate over what they are to do in regard to Arunachal, the Chinese do not remember the success they have achieved in Aksai Chin?
Arun Shouri
The Indian Express, 12.2.2008
Title "Shipla Shetty Trumps Arunachal again"

Chinese Incursions Inside Arunachal Pradesh

(Part III)
1. Similarly, to deal with China, to counter Pakistan's proxy war, the country must sustain a policy for 20-30 years. And for that, you have to keep readers and viewers focused on that issue for decades at a time. But the media is fixated only on what it can project as 'breaking news' in this shift – what was 'breaking news' in the last shift is 'old hat' by this one.
2. This weak-kneed government is a problem, of course: its nominal leaders have lifted helplessness to new heights. But the even graver problem now is that the one instrument, by which it could be shaken up, the media, has become a problem of its own.
3. Make no mistake: China watches all this. It watches the feeble, confused, contradictory ways in which our government, and even more our society, reacts each time it advances a claim. And it pursues its policy:
Claim;
Repeat the claim;
Go on repeating the claim
Grab;
Hold;
Let time pass.
And they will reconcile themselves to the new situation. Has the policy not succeeded in regard to Tibet? No Indian Prime Minister will dare mention the word Tibet or Taiwan' – lest doing so offends China. But China will go on claiming what it wants – for reasons that we must understand.
4. But why think of Tibet and Taiwan? Has the six-step policy not succeeded in regard to Aksai Chin? In spite of the unanimous resolution that the Parliament passed at the time under Panditji, is there an Indian leader who will today demand that China hand back Aksai Chin? And do you think that when they deliberate over what they are to do in regard to Arunachal, the Chinese do not remember the success they have achieved in Aksai Chin?
Arun Shouri
The Indian Express, 12.2.2008
Title "Shipla Shetty Trumps Arunachal again"

Chinese Incursions Inside Arunachal Pradesh

(Part II)
1. Cartographic aggression takes several forms. Some overt, as in the case of Iraq, others more subtle. In 1993 I received a book titled Physical Geography of China, written by Zhao Sonqiao, published in 1986 in Beijing. On the frontispiece is a map of China. But that map, to the trained eye, looks a bit strange. Why? Because in the south, it takes from India virtually all of the Indian state of Arunachal Pradesh, plus a piece of the state of Assam. Now this book is not a political geography of China, nor is the matter of appropriated Indian territory ever discussed in it. China's border is simply assumed to lie deep inside India, and the mountains and valleys thus claimed are discussed as though they are routinely a part of China. Make no mistake: such a map could not, in the 1980s at least have been published without official approval. It should put not just India but the whole international community on notice of a latent trouble spot.
2. When Acharya Kripalani, Ram Manohar Lohia, K.M. Munishi and others had first drawn attention to Chinese maps that showed vast swathes of Indian territory to be part of China, Panditji had replied that he had taken up the matter with the Chinese and they had said these were old, colonial, faulty maps, and, as they had just gained independence, they had not had time to correct them. Later, these very maps were used to argue that the areas had always been part of China. Mao had then declared, Tibet is the palm of China, and the Himalayan kingdoms are the fingers of that palm.
3. Did the journalists not remember any of this? One is the premise of many: India can never really be in the right: you just have to see the play Musharraf's devious formulae have got in many of our magazines the presumption is that we are in the wrong in Kashmir, and so we are the ones who must bend, and go on bending till Pakistan expresses satisfaction. This premise is compounded in the case of many others by commitment you can rely on several of our colleagues to see merit in China's stance on everything. The second variant is domestic predilection: the BJP is evil incarnate: because the BJP had raised the issue, the issue itself must be trashed. That is how the mortal danger from Bangladeshi infiltrators has been shouted out. That is how the dual faced, anti national politics of many in Kashmir has been shouted out. That is how appeasement of narrow sections for votes is routinely shouted out. That is how what is happening in Arunachal is being shouted out.
4. And then there is what has become the nature of the media: the obsession with the sound bite on the one side and with the next 'breaking news' on the other. Issues like Kashmir, the nuclear deal, the way China is translating its economic strength into military might these require more than a sound bite. The media has no time for that.
Arun Shouri
The Indian Express, 12.2.2008
Title "Shipla Shetty Trumps Arunachal again"

Chinese Incursions Inside Arunachal Pradesh

(Part I)
1. Chinese soldiers were coming in deeper into our territory.
2. There had been 146 incursions in just 2007.
3. The Chinese were now preventing locals from going up to regions where they had been taking their animals for grazing;
4. There had been a statue of the Buddha well inside Indian Territory. Local inhabitants used to go up to it - pray, make their offerings. The local commander of the Chinese troops had told Indian soldiers that the statue must be removed. Our soldiers had pointed out that the statue was well within Indian Territory, and so there was no question of removing it. The Chinese had come, and blown off the status.
5. Why Geography Matters, by the well-known geographer, Harm de Blij. Setting the stage, Blij points to the clues that one can get from maps, and why it is important to pay attention to them - especially when governments publish them. He recall 'a telling experience he had in 1990. A colleague of his, working then at the University of Baghdad, had sent him an official map that had been published by the Government of Iraq. The map showed Kuwait as the 13th province of Iraq. At a meeting in Washington, Blij had drawn the attention of the then chairman of the foreign affairs committee of the US House of Representatives to the map and its implications. The gentleman had told Blij not to worry, the US Ambassador, he said, was on top of things. A few days had not passed, and Iraq had marched its armies into Kuwait. The first Gulf War….
Arun Shouri
The Indian Express, 12.2.2008
Title "Shipla Shetty Trumps Arunachal again"

Madarasas are used to store arms and ammunition

Anti India activities are spreading
- The Intelligence Agencies Survey
1. The intelligence agencies are conducting discreet survey to verify the extent of change in the demographic profile of areas bordering Nepal and the Northeast.
2. "There have been reports that more madarsas and mosques are sprouting along the borders, which in itself is an indication of increased Muslim population in the area," disclosed intelligence official.
3. It was ultimately leaked and the estimated number of illegal migrants from Bangladesh was anywhere between 1.5 crore and 2 crore.
4. There have been renewed intelligence reports that militants are using madarsas and mosques as safe havens, and also for storing arms and ammunition.
5. The largest number of madrsas and mosques has come up in bordering areas with Nepal, lower Assam and Bengal. This complements another secret survey that has revealed that nearly 40 per cent villages in the border districts of Bengal are predominantly Muslim.
6. There are reports that concentration of the minority community, including the Bangladeshi immigrants in the villages, has resulted in the majority community moving to urban areas.
7. Along with madarsas and mosques, a large number of Muslim NGO's have sprung up in the area bordering Nepal.
8. "The NGOs have also been promoting ill-will against India among the Nepalese Muslim community by circulating propaganda material received from Pakistan and else where, criticising India's treatment of its minorities."
The Telegraph
Demography survey on eastern border - Bhavna Vij – Arora
13th Feb. 2008

Highlights of National Council, New Delhi

28, 29 January, 2008
Historical Decision:-
• The BJP has set a milestone in Indian politics by amending its constitution to make provision for 33 percent reservation for women in organisational posts. Party National Council approved a proposal in this regard with a Voice Vote.
• With this decision, one third of the posts in local, mandal, district, state and national executive of the party would be reserved for women. Provisions have also been made to make national and state president of the Mahila Morcha ex-officio members of the central and the state election committees.
Shri L.K. Advani:-
• The Leader of Opposition flayed Mr. Manmohan Singh stewardship, describing him as a weak and ineffective Prime Minister. As things stand, 7, Race Course Road, is not as important as 10, Janpath. He cited the left as another centre of authority.
• Describing the present arrangement as the "Kremlinisation of Indian" the BJP leader draw parallels from the time when the communists where ruling the Soviet Union, where the chairman of the communist party was accorded precedence over the country’s president.
Shri Rajnath Singh:-
• Government should legally define the term minority and appropriately determine in what spheres it would be applicable. UPA is communalising the development process.
• Demanded the setting up of a Real Estate Regulatory Authority. ( Interest rates on home loans, education and farm loans should be reduced )
• Government should investigate the possibility of terrorists using Indian stock markets to park their money.
• UPA Government humiliates the sentiments of the Hindus through its affidavit on Ram Sethu. ( Ram Rajya was the model projected by Mahatma Gandhi. Raghupathy Ragav Raja Ram was the daily prayer of Gandhiji. Such a faith on Ram was rediculed by the Congress in the ASI Affidavit. It is shameful )
Shri Narendra Modi:-
• Border security, communication network, finance and banking are the responsibility of the Central Government. If these three areas are secured, terrorism can be put under check.

Let Us Celebrate The Victory of Bharatiya Mazdoor Sangh

Again, B.M.S. Is No. 1 Among The Top Trade Unions Of The Country
• Bharatiya Mazdoor Sangh, an affiliate labour movement of the Sangh Vichar Dhara, has emerged as the largest trade Union in the country with a record membership of 62, 15, 797. Equally significant is that this number is nearly double that of the total membership of the 2nd largest union, INTUC, the Congress Party’s labour wing, whose membership is 39, 54, 012. The most striking aspect is the decline of CITU, the Trade Union Wing of the CPI(M), which slipped to the fifth position with just 26, 78, 473 members behind the AITUC and HMS.
• The verification process of the central trade unions took five years to complete. The final figures were announced last weak. The commandable B.M.S. growth is a befitting tribute to the great trade union founder, the late Dattopant Thengadi. He founded the BMS and nursed and nourished it by his exceptional zeal, hard work, vision and seer like tenacity.
• The BMS has been maintaining the lead for the last many years, but this is the highest it has reached and for the CPM labour wing this is the lowest ever. The CPM has maintained an eloquent silence ever since the Labour Ministry’s verified final figures were announced. The verification execrcise is conducted every ten years and it is considered the most defining moment for trade unions as it determines the representation levels to the unions in the national and international conferences and committees. The left unions were also wiped out in the recently held first ever elections through secret ballot at the Indian Railways. They have also been losing ground in major public sector units like BHEL, and Banking Institutions.
Organizer, Weekly
31.1.2008

HOW TO MAKE 'ANTI-INCUMBENCY' FACTOR INTO " PRO-INCUMBENCY" VICTORY?

• Congress is hoping to return to power in Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, and Chhattisgarh on the basis of the "Anti-Incumbency" factor. However Gujarat has shown that the "anti-incumbency" factor can be overcome.
• During the time available before the Assembly polls, I would like those in Government and in the party organization, as well as the MLAs, in these States to attend to four cardinal tasks:
• Speed up and further improve the functioning of the Government, especially in areas of development and people's welfare.
• Go among the people and explain to them the Government achievements. It is necessary to improve the coordination between the Government and party organization with the Chief Minister clearly representing the unity of command.
• Go among the people also to find out what they have to say about the performance of BJP MLAs Ministers and Government in general, and take corrective measures wherever necessary. Often, people's displeasure over a local MLA or MP hurts the party, as we saw at the time of the 2004 parliamentary election.
• Lastly, expeditious steps should be taken to address internal dissensions, factionalism. etc., for which there can be simply no place in the BJP.
(Excerpted from Mr. LK Advani's concluding remarks at the BJP National Council meeting on January 29, 2008)

How we are going to be different from the Congress and the UPA ?

The best way of creating a nationwide urge for a BJP led NDA Government at the Centre is to effectively communicate to the people how we are going to be different from the Congress and the UPA. We must - and we shall - be different from them on every count on which we have been criticising them on.
• The days of weak leadership at the top will be over.
• There shall be no compromise in the fight against terrorism and Maoism. We shall deal with this twin menace with a heavy hand.
• Corruption at the top will not be tolerated.
• We shall make a sincere and determined effort to ensure that more and more common people, in villages as well as in towns and cities, are able to live better lives. For this, India's economic growth will have to be further speeded up, made more broad-based geographically and socially and most importantly re-oriented for greater employment generation.
• What we stand for has been captured in the three commitments that have begun to gain currency especially after BJP's victory in Gujarat. These are Good Governance, Development and Security.
• If some parties in India wish to be guided by foreign-born ideologies and foreign-born leadership they will certainly realise the limitations of doing so. As shocking indication of how little respect these parties have for India's cultural-civilisation heritage is the stand they have taken on the Ram Setu issue. The UPA Government went to the extent of filing an affidavit in the Supreme Court denying the very existence of Lord Ram and the historicity of the Ramayana.
(Excerpted from Mr. LK Advani's concluding remarks at the BJP National Council meeting on January 29, 2008)

Can the NDA win a clear Majority ? My Answer is "Yes, we can"

- L. K. Advani
I was looking at the results of all the six Lok Sabha elections since 1989, when the BJP rose like a phoenix from its lowest figure of two MPs in 1984. I see that so far the BJP has won at least once from as many 297 Lok Sabha constituencies on its own since 1989. Many of them have been won by the BJP several times over. And if we include the additional 64 constituencies from which the BJP's stable allies in the NDA - Akali Dal, Shiv Sena, Janata Dal and Biju Janata Dal have won at least once since 1989, the total number of such constituencies represented by the NDA comes to 361. This means that we are already a formidable alliance and, if we work unitely and with a credible agenda of change that appeals to the people, the NDA can indeed win a decisive majority.
As far the BJP is concerned, it should be our firm resolve this time to scale higher than our highest point of achievement so far. After 1984 our graph had been steadily going up from one election after another. It is only in 2004 that we suffered a setback. Now whether elections are held in 2008 or 2009 the BJP's strength should surpass what it was in 1999.
In planning our election strategy aimed at winning a decisive mandate, we should, of course, recognise an important feature about the current political map of India. In several states, which together account for a sizeable number of seats in Parliament, neither the BJP nor our current allies in the NDA has a strong presence. Therefore, even if the people in these States, like their counterparts else where, want to see a strong Government with a decisive mandate at the Centre, they feel constrained by State specific conditions. We saw in 2004 how the final out come of the parliamentary election became somewhat of an aggregate of separate State-specific outcomes.
We will have to overcome this dichotomy. For this purpose. I would like to persuasively tell our friends in those regional political parties that are strong in these states. If you really wish to see a positive change at the Centre, let us together strengthen our common battle against the UPA Government. The NDA has recently passed a resolution to contest the next general election on the basis of a common agenda of governance.
In this context, I have a special appeal to make to anti-communist parties in West Bengal and Kerala. Please do not be under the illusion that either the Communists will completely and irreversibly sever their links with the Congress or that the Congress will abandon the Communists. The Communists are supporting the Congress at the Centre today, and they will do so again in the future if the need arises. This being the case, the only way to defeat the Communists in West Bengal and Kerala is by strengthening the NDA.
(Excerpted from Mr. LK Advani's concluding remarks at the BJP National Council meeting on January 29, 2008)

INDO CHINESE DISPUTE

Story so far :-
1914, the British and Tibetans signed an agreement defining the eastern border through the MCMahon Line. The Chinese representative initiatted the agreement but did not sign.
February 1951, Maj. Bob Khating took over Tawang, the most important town in the then North-East Frontier Agency, now Arunachal Pradesh. China did not protest.
1954, Indian Maps showed Aksai Chin border as "undefined". Thereafter, India unilaterally changed its maps, claimed the area.
1956, China built a road in the region without India's knowledge and consolidated itself there. Staked claim only in 1958.
1960, 1981, a swap of claims was proposed, but the Chinese have maintained their claim to the Tawang tract, till the Se La Pass.
China is keen to retain a major portion of the Aksai-Chin region it already controls because the road linking Xinjiang with Tibet runs through it, India wants to hold on to the Tawang tract because there is a settled population of Indian nationals residing there.
The border between India and China is currently defined by a 4,056 km Line of Actual Control (LAC) which is neither marked on the ground nor on mutually acceptable maps. Efforts to have a recognized LAC since the mid 1980s through a joint working group (JWG) of officials and experts have made little headway.
China is still holding a large chunk of territory in Kashmir, 38000 sqkm (14,670 sqmiles) of Aksai Chin which it seized after the 1962 blatant invasion, and claims more .
Another 5, 180 sqkm (2000 sqmiles) of northern Kashmir was given by Pakistan to Beijing as price for an all weather friendship pact signed in 1963.
China had already built a road through Aksai Chin linking Tibet with its Xinjiang province before it laid an aggressive claim on it. Now it seeks a political solution, not a technical one, to the border problem. In other words, since Aksai Chin highway helps China to maintain control over the region, it is politically more important to China than to India.
The key guiding principles to be approved include one of not disturbing "settled populations" and the need to take into account each other's security concerns, including related logistical arrangements. A preliminary under standing of these principles applied along the existing Line of Actual Control (LAC) could persuade China to give up its claim to most of the Tawang tract, and India to do the same with a significant portion of Aksai Chin. These are the two most contentious areas on the disputed 4,056 km Indo-China border.
These parameters and guidelines have been the subject of intense behind the scenes negotiations since the June 2003 visit of Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee to Beijing.
It was during this visit that the two sides decided that their tangled border, currently marked only by an LAC, could only be resolved through political intervention and not through endless negotiations on claims and counter-claims.
Hindustan Times, 26 March 2005

0.2 percent of our people are growing at 9.92% per annum

• In a speech at a CII meet, Mani Shankar Aiyar argued that policy is hijacked by a small elite. That the cabinet he belongs to is quite comfortable with this hijacking. That India’s system of governance is such that Rs 650 crore for village development is considered wasteful but Rs 7,000 crore for the Commonwealth Games is considered vital. The classes rule all the time, Aiyar says, the masses get a look-in every five years
• We rank eighth in the world in the number of our millionaires. And we stand 126th on the Human Development Index.
• At this very fast rate of growth that we are now showing, we moved up from 127th to 126th position.
• Every five years, it is the masses who determine who will form the government. And in between those five years the classes determine what that government will do.
• So when you talk of a nine point two per cent growth rate, it becomes a statistical abstraction: 0.2 per cent of our people are growing at 9.92 per cent per annum. But there is a very large number, I don’t know how many, whose growth rate is perhaps down to 0.2 per cent. But certainly, the number of those who are at the lower end of the growth sector is very much larger than those who are at the higher end.
• We have seen what happened at Nandigram, we have seen what was happening at Singur. You go to Hirakud, which is where Jawaharlal Nehru actually used the expression modern temples of India, and you ask what happened to the tribals who were driven out of there. Absolutely nobody knows.
• There is nobody so marginal in a government as the minister of Panchayati Raj. I count for nothing. Nothing! When I was the minister of petroleum, I used to walk surrounded by this media. I kept on telling them that petrol prices can do only three things — go up, go down or remain where they are. And it was all over the place. But try and get them to write two words about the 700 million Indians — absolutely impossible. And now with terrestrial television it is even worse. You have to be quarreling with your mother-in-law or hitting your daughter-in-law to be able to hit the headlines. It is impossible to get particularly the pink papers to focus on issues that affect the bulk of the people. And it is so easy to get them to focus on issues that are of high relevance to only one or two per cent of the people.
(Edited extracts from a speech at the CII Northern Region annual meeting 2006-07, New Delhi, April 4)
Mani Shankar Aiyar Tuesday, April 24, 2007 , The Indian Express

Rural job guarantee scheme an eyewash?

• The National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme is neither national, nor does it guarantee anything: that, in sum, is the finding of a study conducted after the scheme, put in place by the National Rural Employment Guarantee Act of 2005, has completed a little over a year in operation.
• The scheme, with a budgetary allocation of Rs 11,300 crore (Rs 113 billion)?in its first year, was made effective February 2, 2006, across 200 districts in 14 states across India. In the current financial year, the scheme has been expanded to 330 districts, and the budgetary provision enhanced to Rs 12,000 crore (Rs 120 billion).
• In essence, the scheme seeks to guarantee a minimum of 100 days of employment to at least one member of each family, in each of the selected districts.
• The survey, conducted in 21 sample districts across 14 states (Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Chhattisgarh, Gujarat, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Jharkhand, Kerala, Madhya Pradesh, Orissa, Rajasthan, Uttarakhand, Uttar Pradesh, and West Bengal), examined the period April 1, 2006- March 31, 2007.
• Ignorance of the nature of the scheme is another factor hampering effective implementation. The survey found that in the 530 surveyed villages, only 45 per cent of registered households had asked for jobs, and only 27 per cent of these had been given official receipts indicating that the administration is aware of the requirement.
• In sum, the situation is thus: firstly, the registration process is difficult; secondly, even when you do register, less than half the number get employment; even when you get employment, less than half the beneficiaries find work in the prescribed time frame; among those who do get work, the pay is less than the prescribed minimum and this pay is often delayed; among those who have registered but not found employment, the unemployment allowance that was promised has not been given.
• This situation has created a knock-on effect, with the intended beneficiaries losing enthusiasm for and interest in the scheme; where the relieving of rural stress was the stated objective, disillusionment has been added to distress - all this at the expense of over Rs 11,000 crore. Rediff Business Desk, 21 September 2007

Consequences Of Appeasement and Pandering :-

• The first consequence is as inevitable as it is obvious: such pandering whets the appetite. Seeing that governments and parties are competing to pander to them, Muslims see that they are doing so only because their community is acting cohesively, as a vote bank. So, they act even more as a bank of votes.
• For the same reason, a competition is ignited within the community: to prove that he is more devoted to the community than his rival, every would be leader of the community demands more and more from governments and parties. When the concession he demanded has been made, he declares. 'It is not being implemented'. And he has a ready diagnosis: because implementation, he declares, is in the hands of non-Muslims. Hence, unless Muslims officers are appointed in the financial institutions meant for Muslims. With demand following demand, with secularist upon secularist straining himself to urge the demands, the leader sets about looking for grievances that he can fan, when he can't find them, he invents them.
• Government make the fatal mistake, or – as happened in the case of the British when they announced separate electorates for Muslims – they play the master-stroke: they proffer an advantage to the community which that community, Muslims in this case, can secure only by being separate- whether this be separate electorates in the case of Lord Minto or separate financial institutions in the case of Manmohan Singh.
• The community in its turn beings to assess every proposal, every measure, howsoever secular it may be, against one touchstone alone: 'what can we extract from this measure for Muslims as Muslims? How current the description rings that Cantwell Smith gave in his book, Modern Islam in India, published in the 1940s, of the effect that the British stratagem of instituting separate electorates for Muslims had on the Muslim mind. The separate electorates led Muslims, as they had been designed to lead them, he observed, 'to vote communally, think communally, look for constitutional and other reforms only in terms of more relative communal power, and express their grievances communally.' Exactly the same consequence will follow from implementing the Sachar proposal – and the reason for that is simple: the essential point about the proposals is the same – that is, the Muslims can obtain them by being separate from the rest of the country.
• The reaction cannot but set in. 'As Muslims are being given all this because they have distanced themselves from the rest of us, why should we cling to them?' the Hindus are bound to ask. 'On the contrary we should learn from them. Governments and political parties are pandering to Muslims because the latter have become a bank of votes. We should knit ourselves into a solid bloc also.
What more is needed to stoke reaction ?
Indian Express 29/12/2007
Arun Shourie

RECOMMANDATIONS OF SACHAR COMMITTEE AND ITS CONSEQUENCES:-

And what does the Sachar Committee recommend?
• Recognition of the degrees from madrassas for eligibility in competitive examinations such as the civil services, banks, defence services and other such examinations?
• It recommends that a higher proportion of Muslims be inducted in offices that deal with the public-' the teaching community, health workers, police personnel, bank employees and so on.' It recommends ' provision of equivalence' to madrassa certificates/degrees for subsequent admissions into institutions of higher level of education'.
• It recommends that advances be made to Muslims as part of the obligation imposed on banks to give advances to Priority Sectors.
• It recommends the adoption of ' alternate admission criteria' in universities and autonomous colleges: assessment of merit should not be assigned more than 60 per cent out of the total- the remaining 40 per cent should be assigned in accordance with the income of the household the backwardness of the district, and the backwardness of the caste and occupation of the family.
• It recommends changes in the way constituencies are delimited. It recommends that where Muslims are elected or selected in numbers less than adequate, 'a carefully conceived' nomination' procedure' be worked out 'to increase the participation of minorities at the grass roots.'
• It is imperative that if the minorities have certain perceptions of being aggrieved', notice the touchstone-'if the minorities have certain perceptions of being aggrieved ' 'all efforts should be made by the state to find a mechanism by which these complaints could be attended to expeditiously.
What more in needed to stoke reaction ?
Indian Express 29/12/2007
Arun Shourie

MADRASSAS WERE REINFORCING SEPERATENESS

• The Task Force on Border Management, one of the four that were set up in the wake of the Kargil War, reported with alarm about the way madrassas had mushroomed along India's borders. On the basis of information it received from intelligence agencies, it expressed grave concern at the amount of money these madrassas were receiving from foreign sources.
• It reported that large numbers were being educated in these institutions in subjects that did not equip them at all for jobs – other than to become preachers and teachers producing the same type of incendiary unemployables.
• It expressed the gravest concern at the way the madrassas were reinforcing separateness in those attending them- through the curriculum, through the medium of instruction through the entire orientation of learning: the latter, the Task Force pointed out, was entirely turned towards Arabia, towards the golden ages of Islamic rule. It pointed to the consequences that were certain to flow from the Talibanisation of the madrassas.
• In spite of what the Task Forces themselves advised, namely that their reports be made public, the reports have been kept secret. Accordingly, I have summarised the observations of the Task Forces in some detail in Will the Iron Fence save a Tree Hollowed by Termites? Defence imperatives beyond the military, ASA Delhi 2005]


Author: Shri Arun Shourie,
I E 29/12/07

HINDUTAVA AND RADICAL ISLAM: WHERE THE TWAIN DO MEET

• Every set of scriptures has in it enough to justify extreme, even violent reaction. The tectonic shift in the Hindu mind, that has been going on for 200 years, is being underestimated.
• In the great work, Gita Rahasya, that he wrote in the Mandalay prison, the Lokmanya invokes Sri Samartha, "Meet boldness with boldness; Large heartedness towards those who are grasping? Forgiveness towards those who are cruel? ‘Even Prahlada, that highest of devotees of the Blessed Lord,’ the Lokmanya recalls, has said, ‘Therefore, my friend, wise men have everywhere mentioned exceptions to the principle of forgiveness’.
• The mistake is to assume that the sterner stance is something that has been fomented by this individual or that in the case of Hindutva, by say, Veer Savarkar or by one organisation, say the RSS or the VHP. That is just a comforting mistake the inference is that once that individual is calumnised, once that organisation is neutralised, ‘the problem will be over. Large numbers do not gravitate to this interpretation rather than that merely because an individual or an organisation has advanced it. They gravitate to the harsher rendering because events convince them that it alone will save them.
• Instigating factors:-
The more aggressively the other religions proselytise – look at the fervour with which today the Tablighi Jamaat goes about conversion; look at the organised way in which the missionaries ‘harvest’ our souls;
The more they use money to increase the harvest whether it is Saudi money or that of Rome and the American churches;
The more any of them uses violence to enlarge its sway.
From within India, three factors in particular will make the acquiring of that Islamic body all the more certain.
The more biased ‘secularist’ discourse is.
The more political parties use non Hindus, Muslims for instance as vote banks and the more that non Hindu group comes to act as one –‘strategic voting’. The more the state of India bends to these exclusivist, aggressive traditions.
• M.F. Husain. He is a kindly man, his depictions of Hindus goddesses have been in the news; he has painted them in less than skimpy attire. How come he has never felt inspired to paint women revered in Islam, or in his own family, in the same style as the one that propelled his inspiration in regard to Hindu goddesses?
• When Muslims start behaving like a vote bank you can be certain that someone will get the idea that Hindus too should be welded into a vote bank, and eventually they will get welded into one.
ARUN SHOURIE
28/12/2007

Tibetan spirit of freedom will remain indomitable

-Dalai Lama
• In an exclusive interview with The Indian Express, the Dalai Lama sounded a note of caution for New Delhi, saying Tibetans were the "first line of defence" for India all along the Line of Actual Control (LAC) but this situation may completely change with the huge influx of Han Chinese all set to alter Tibet’s demographic profile.
• While he has taken note of the UPA government’s recent circular asking Cabinet Ministers to stay away from the functions he attends, the Dalai Lama urged New Delhi to take up the case of "meaningful autonomy" with Beijing as "it is ultimately a matter of safety of the 4,000-km long border from Arunachal Pradesh to Ladakh."
• "Way back on March 10, 1969, I had said that it was time for the Tibetan people to decide whether to continue with the institution of Dalai Lama... In 1992, I was willing to hand over legal authority for certain degrees of freedom in Tibet... Since 2001, I am in a semi-retirement position with all political authority now vested in the government-in-exile... I am now looking forward to complete retirement," the Dalai Lama said.
• He said it was for the Tibetan people to decide on the method for his succession. This included the following: Like the Pope is appointed by the cardinals of the Roman Catholic Church on the principles of seniority or a reincarnation being recognised before his death or the traditional manner.
• But given the earlier controversy over the succession of the Panchen Lama and Beijing’s recent diktat that makes it mandatory for all reincarnate lamas to be officially recognised by the Chinese government, the Dalai Lama fears Beijing will complicate his succession. "Just like the Panchen Lama succession, the Chinese will also choose an official Dalai Lama... so there will be two Dalai Lamas, one chosen and other official... similar to two Panchen Lamas... But the real Dalai Lama will have a Tibetan heart and my people will not accept the official Dalai Lama," he said.
• Responding to a question that Beijing always believes Tibet was part of China, the Dalai Lama said there was need for legal experts and historians to study the relationship between the Chinese emperor and the Tibetan religious leadership in the past before coming to such a conclusion.
• "The Chinese first called the cultural revolution a great achievement.. then said there was some achievement and some destruction and now finally admit that there was total destruction during that period... You cannot change history on the basis of political necessity... the Chinese create certain positions, no matter whether they are based on reality or not," he said.
• Giving details of his government’s dialogue with the Chinese government, the Dalai Lama said Beijing’s position had hardened in the last round, the sixth, in which they made it clear there was "no Tibet issue" and the "only issue was Dalai Lama."
• While he maintains that the Tibetan spirit for freedom will remain indomitable, he fears that time is running out for a just resolution of the Tibetan issue with the huge influx of the Han Chinese from the mainland with official support.
• According to him, the Han Chinese make 200,000 out of Lhasa’s total population of 300,000 and the figures are constantly rising. "If Tibet becomes a land of Han Chinese, then even autonomy will be meaningless," the Dalai Lama said.
-----------------------------------------------------------
Shishir Gupta, Tuesday, January 22, 2008
The Indian Express

How Best to address the Farmer's Problems

• The distress of the farmers has been aggravated by the decline in earnings from agricultural operations, the cost of inputs, the commercialisation of agriculture and the dependence on money lenders.
• The suicide by farmers in several states has highlighted the problem of indebtedness as the central issue.
• High indebtedness offsets the process of credit recycling, impedes production and productivity and forces a person into the debt trap.
• The institutional credit has expanded rapidly after bank nationalisation and more so over the last 3 years. From Rs 1865 crores in 1971-72 to Rs 86,981 crores in 2003-04, it nearly doubled to Rs. 1,80,486 cores in 2005-06 during 2006-07, it reached Rs 2,03,296 crore. Despite this, the credit needs of agriculture have not been fully met.
• The debt of the farmer households was estimated at Rs. 1.12 lakh crore in 2003, of which 48,000 crore was from non-institutional agencies including money-lenders. Nearly 74% of the debt from non-institutional agencies was at interest rates exceeding 20% per annum and in some cases 30% per annum.
• Why do farmers borrow from money lenders at interest rates which are much higher than those charged by banks? Many farmers face problems in gaining access to banks, then the problem of rigidity, insistance on a collateral, in adequate loans and procedural delay. These are the major reasons why the rural people approach non-institutional agencies.
• The indebtedness stems from the uncertainty over the monsoon rainfall. The return from the crop cultivation is not always assured. Though the aqricultural credit has increased, most of the farmers depend on non-institutional sources and exploitative terms and conditions.
• The dominance of middlemen often prevents the farmers from getting remunerative prices for their produce. The farmers often have to take loans for social functions and medical expenses from money lenders at a still higher rate of interest.
• The expert group's suggestions on increasing agricultural productivity, enhancing investments in agricultural infrastructure, research and extension, putting in place an effective system of risk mitigation both in production and marketing area are important aspects to be implemented.
• Indian agriculture is largely rainfed. The other factor is commercialisation. The farmer thus gets exposed to production as well as market risks.
• There is a need for an aquaculture risk fund to provide relief to the farmers through the banking system. If there are two failures in a span of 3 to 5 years, the fund could be used for writing off the principal loan amount.
• The farmers feel neglected and are quite distressed. Half measures or generous pronouncements won't do. Agriculture and farmers need should be at the centre stage of the planning system. A high powered standing committee ought to review the flow of agricultural credit.
- Balasaheb Vikhe Patil
Statesman 18/1/2008

DODA KILLINGS

1999 : 15 January : 16 Hindus killed in Barshalla, 17 Hindus killed in Sumber area same District of Doda
1997 : 25 and 26 January : 25 Kashmiri Pandit killed in Vundhawa of Shrinagar tonight
24 June : 8 Hindu Killed in Swari of Rajori
1998 : 19 June : 25 Hindu were killed in Chapneri of Doda
8 August : 35 Labour were killed in Kalaban of Chamba Districts Border
18 april : 27 people were killed in prankoat of Districts Doda
1999 : 19 July : 15 people killed in Layata of Doda
2000 : 2 August : 7 people were killed of the same family in Kupwarda
1 August : 27 Labour killed in Kazigund and Aachabal of Aanatnag
1 August : 31 Amarnath Pilgrims were killed in Pahalgam
20 March : 35 Sikhs killed in Chhattsighpura near of Jammu
28 Feb. : 5 Hindu driver killed nearby Kazigund
2001 : 4 August : 15 Hindu killed in Shrotidar village of Doda
22 July : 15 Hindu killed in Chirangi and Tagoad of Doda
21 July : 7 Pilgrims together 13 killed in Sheshnag of Anatnag
17 March : 8 were killed in District Aatholi of Doda
11 Feb. : 15 Gjjar killedi n Kotchatwal of Rajori
3 Feb : 6 Sikh where shot at in Mahjuranagar of Shrinagar
2002 : 2 November : 14 people were killed and 53 inured in Terrorist attach in Raghunath Temple of Jammu
2002 : 20 August : 10 Hindu killed In District Rajori and Doda
6 August : 9 Amarnath Pilgrims were killed and 32 injured in Nunwana nearby Pahalgam
13 July : 28 Hindu killed in Kasimnagar
14 May : 33 people killed along with women and children in terrorist attack on Jammu Pathankot
hoghway in the Army Military Camp and Bus.
17 Feb : 8 Hindu shot at in District Rajori
7 Jan. : 17 Hindu killed in District Ramsu of Jammu
2003 : 4 march : 24 Kashmiri Pandit killed by terrorist in District Pulwama Soapiyan
nearby Nadimarg village
2004 : 5 April : 7 people killedin Pahalgam of Aanatnag
2006 : 1 May : 27 Hindu killed in Village Panjdobi and Thawa of Doda

Mandal Commission

• The plan to set up a Commission was taken by Morarji Desai Government in 1978.
• The decision was made official by the President on January 1, 1979
• So finally the "Mandal Commission" was established in 1979 by the Janata Party Government under Prime Minister Morarji Desai.
• The AIM was to "Identify Socially or Educationally Backward" people of our country.
• It was Headed by Indian Parliamentarian BHINDESHWARI PRASAD MANDAL to consider the question of seat reservation and quotas for people.
• The Commission adopted 11 criteria which could be grouped under 3 major headings.
I Social
II Educational
III Economic
in order to Identity OBC
• The report of the Commission was submitted in December 1980.
• It called for reserving 27% of all services and public sector undertakings under the Central Government and 27% of all admission to institutions of higher education except in states that have reserved higher % of Quota.
• A decade after the Commission gave its report, V.P. Singh, the then Prime Minister of that time tried to implement its recommendation in 1989.
• The decision of implementation of Mandal Commissions, recommendation, generaed severe controversy.
• Colleges across the country held massive protests against it. Anti Mandal criticism was shape.
• Rajiv Goswamy, student, of Delhi University self immolated himself in protest of the Government action.
• His act further sparked a series of self - immolation by other colleges.

India & China : It is a challenge to the Leadership which is capable of handling problems

T J S George
26.11.2006
For some 200 years ending AD 90, Vietnam was Chinese province. In early 15th century it was again re-conquered by china and it again drove the invaders out. As late as in Deng Hsiaoping's time, there was yet another unpublished border war. It was again Vietnamese forces that prevailed.
How did they do this? The straight answer is: Unity. Nothing in history matches the power of Vietnamese nationalism and no national leader, not excluding Mahatma Gandhi, united his people as effectively as Ho Chi Minh did. Before the force of that united national resolve, the Chinese, then the French, then the Americans with history's most powerful was machine, had to flee.
Of the many factors that enabled China to defeat India in the 1962 war, perhaps the most important was the absence of unity in India. Generals disagreed among themselves. The army disagreed with the Air Force. Cabinet colleagues disagreed with the Defence Minister who disagreed with the politicians. India's backroom battles led to its front line defeat. China remains conscious of this Indian weakness.
China is of course a highly pragmatic country. It will do its best to build up relations with the big consumer/investment market that is India. But on its terms. Behind the modern sophistication of China's announced world game is the unalterable resolve to be Asia's leading power. It already has a clear lead and will gain further ground if only because China looks a hundred years ahead while our leaders cannot see beyond the next election.
See what China has already achieved. Borders neatly defined with every neighbour except India. The engineering feat of a train to Tibet achieved. Road networks expanding across the Indian border regions. Relations established with anti-Indian elements in Burma and Bangladesh. And of course powerful links, including nuclear, forged with Pakistan.
What have we got to show against this? There is not a single neighbour with whom we have good and healthy relations. We have no policy in Kashmir where things have gone from bad to worse. We have no policy towards containing Bangladeshi infiltration which now threatens to reverse the population pattern in several border regions. We have no policy for the critically important northeast states which we treat as a law and order problem. An editor in Assam has warned that it will be difficult to hold on to the northeast after another ten years. To this day people in Nagaland and nearby states see India as a foreign country, which Indians call them Chinese.
There is a grievous disconnect in India between the attainable and the attained. Sure, China has grievous problems too : Dangerous regional imbalances, dangerous gaps between rich and poor, rising demands for political freedoms. But they have a leadership that has proved itself capable of handling the problems.
Can we say the same about our leaders? Their main concerns are caste killings in Bihar, kidnappings in UP, minority persecution in Gujarat and water wars in the southern states. This India will not recapture the glory of its past or fulfil the promise of its future. It's only good for 10 percent rate. For whom ? For what ?

RAM SETHU III (Govt. withrawal of Affidavit)

• The BJP leader also wanted the government to fix ministerial responsibility, and give an undertaking that the Ram Sethu, which was described as a symbol of faith for millions of people would be protected.
• In the name of secularism, anti Hinduism manifests itself from time to time. I believe that the touchstone of secularism should be the crucial question-what is often said against the Hindus, can it be hurled against other religions? I dare the secularists to say such things even indirectly aginst other religions and other symbols," he said.
• "The issue pertains to the culture and unity of the country. It concerns genuine secularism," Mr Advani remarked. He saw the contents of the affidavit in the same league as prime minister Manmohan Singh's "Muslims-have-the-first-claim-on-resources" statement. "I believe that our Constitution and the country's political ethos mandates the first claim on resources on the hungry and the poor, regardless of their religious background. Will we have communal budgeting in the future. I consider it as an example of communalism," he argued. The Economic Times 14.9.2007
AFFIDAVIT WITHDRAWN
• The Centre announced on Thursday that it would withdraw objectionable paragraphs in the affidavit filed by the Archaeological Survey of India in the Supreme Court which said that there was no evidence to prove "the existence of the characters or the occurrence of the events"
• Mr. Bhardwaj said: "Lord Rama is an integral part of Indian culture and ethos and cannot be a matter of debate or subject matter of litigation in court."
• He said a wrong impression had been created by media reports on the affidavit. "The existence of Rama cannot be doubted. As Himalaya is Himalaya, Ganga is Ganga, Rama is Rama. It is a question of faith. There is no requirement of any proof to establish the existence based on faith."
• Mr. Bhardwaj added: "Rama is inbuilt into the sentiments of Hindus. Indian theology derives its belief . Religion should never be made a subject matter in court." The Hindu 14.9.2007

RAM SETHU-II (Govt. Affidavit and objection of BJP)

GOVERNMENT AFFIDAVIT
• Defending the Sethusamudram shipping canal project and maintaining that the Adam's Bridge/Ram Setu formation cannot be called "a man-made structure" the Centre today told the Supreme Court that "contents of the Valmiki Ramayana, the Ramcharitamanas by Tulsidas and other mythological texts, which admittedly form an important part of ancient Indian literature... cannot be said to be historical record to incontrovertibly prove the existence of the characters, or the occurrence of the events, depicted therein."
OBJECTION TO ASI AFFIDAVIT BY BJP
• Leader of Opposition LK Advani asked Prime Minister Manmohan Singh to immediately withdraw the affidavit claiming it was tantamount to "questioning the faith of millions of Indians."
• BJP called the affidavit an "insult to the cultural heritage, civilisational beliefs, and Hindu sentiments." BJP spokesperson Ravishankar Prasad mounted a spirited assault on the government and wanted to know if the Congress could take a similar stand on any other faith. Prasad said this is a "crude attempt" to insult Hindus, "questioning the very existence of Ram and Sita.
WILL CONGRESS DARE TO DO THIS TO ANY OTHER RELIGION?:- LK ADVANI
• LK Advani, blamed the Manmohan Singh government for practising the worst form of "communalism" and sought an apology from the prime minister and UPA chairperson Sonia Gandhi for "hurting the sentiments of millions of Hindus" across the globe by denying the existence of Lord Ram. "It is clear that the Congress party's pseudo-secularism has degenerated into sadist-secularism," he said.

RAM SETHU - I (SSCP - Project)

What 's the Sethusamudram Shipping Canal Project (SSCP)?
• Dredging 82 million cubic m of the Palk Strait to build a 167- km long channel which will cut sailing time of ships between east and west coasts by 780 km (nearly 30 hours).
• As of now, ships have to circumnavigate Lanka
• Cost: Rs. 2,427 crore
• Deadline: November 30, 2008
What's the "Ram" controversy?
• Sangh Parivar claims the project will destroy the existing Ram Setu (Adam's Bridge) which, according to the Ramayana, was the bridge that Ram and his army (including Vaanar Sena) built to help him reach Sri Lanka to rescure Sita.
What's the science?
• Geological surveys show that Adam's Bridge is merely compact clay, sandstone and limestone deposited over time. Sedimentation pattern points to sea level fluctuations.
What's the current status of the project?
• 5 dredgers at work in the sea off Rameshwaram in the Palk Bay: 23.16 million cubic m dredged so far
• Palk Strait region: 43.2% dredging done
• In the North of Adam's Bridge area, 24.5% dredged
• "Cutter Section" dredger, required for hard rocky area along Adam's Bridge broke in January. Work resumed again in April but this dredger can be used only from October to mid-May.
What's the trouble over ASI?
• It has told SC that legend or mythological texts can't be seen as "historical record"What's angered the BJP is the next phrase: that this isn't proof of the "existence of characters or events" (Ram etc) depicted in these texts. This led the BJP to say the ASI is "doubting the faith of millions".
• ASI says it has to go by tangible evidence- like it did in the Babri Masjid case where it told the court that excavation at the disputed site shows evidence of features" associated with temples".

Nandigram

• Triggered a popular backlash
• Exposed the ugly face of CPI (M)
• Duplicity of the Congress leadership was opposed by one and all
• Sangram CPM lost despite Stalinist brutalities
Nandigram, is situated about 150 km. away from Kolkata. Villagers opposed the government bid to set up a Special Economic Zone. At Nandigram, 10,000 acres is planned to be acquired for a multi - product SEZ. Farmers' land was at stake, about to be written away by the state to the Salim group of Indonesia to set up a Special Economic Zone.
In a shocking display of strong-arm tactics adopted by the Marxist government of West Bengal, thousands of State Policemen, backed by CPM cadre, opened fire on the farmers of Nandigram protesting against forcible acquisition of their agricultural land by the State Government for a Special Economic Zone Project. This utterly shameful, seemingly preplanned act which killed many and left many more injured took place in broad daylight on March 13, turning the green fields of Nandigram into killer fields.
As the police and CPM cadre were jointly perpetrating their orgy of violence and mayhem, the media was barred from entering Nandigram.
This act of brutality unparalleled in independent India shocked the whole country generating widespread protest in Kolkata and calls of bandh from Trinamul Congress and BJP. Both Houses of Parliament were rocked as agitated BJP and Trinamul Congress members forced an adjournment in the Rajya Sabha and staged a walkout in the Lok Sabha. The BJP and Trinamul MPs stormed the well of the House and shouted raised slogans alleging that the Nandigram incident was a repeat of the "Jallianwala Bagh" outrage perpetrated by colonial British rulers.
The BJP took a very strong stand against this State sponsored atrocity. Leader of Opposition, Shri L.K. Advani spoke to Prime Minister, Dr Manmohan Singh and Home Minister, Shri Shivraj Patil requesting them to seek a report from the West Bengal Governor on this violence. Shri Advani called it one of the most unfortunate events since Independence. BJP President Shri Rajnath Singh demanded a judicial or parliamentary probe into the police firing. He said the State Government had lost the moral authority to continue in office.

Friday, 3 October 2008

Danger to Ram Setu

Ram Setu Picture taken by NASA (National Aeronautics & Space Administration), USA from space show the remains of what appears to be an age old, man-made bridge between Rameshwaram and Sri Lanka. According to Hindu scriptures and belief, Lord Ram and his vaanar sena had built a bridge from Rameshwaram to Sri Lanka about 17 lacs 25 thousands year ago. The discovery of Shri Ram Setu by NASA confirms that Hindu scriptures and belief are correct in this matter and that Ramayana is a history and not "mythology" as is often construed.
Setu Samudram shipping canal project is based on the notion that it is inevitable to break the Shri Ram Setu for easy navigation. This will amount to damaging a monument of both, historical and religious importance to Hindus.
Why Ram Setu should not be damaged ?
Ram Setu prevented the tsunami from advancing from Rameshwaram to Kerala.
Besides, this bridge is world's oldest man-made structure. It is much, much older than the pyramids of Egypt, and the Great Wall of China.
Ram Setu has sentimental, religious and historic value.
People have crossed the sea using the Rama-Setu, for many thousand years, until the 15th century.
Better alternative solutions are also available.
According to the specialists, a sea route may be prepared for navigation without damaging Sri Ram Setu, by removing, the barren sand heaps near village Mandapam between Rameshwaram and Dhanushkoti railway. This will not only give a shorter route for navigation but also protect the oldest man-made heritage.

Singur - Can government acquire land for private good ?

Prime fertile agricultural land is being forcibly acquired from peasants in Singur, West Bengal. Singur land, coated with silt from the Hoogly and Damodar rivers and their tributaries, is very fertile. To say that it is single - crop land is blatantly to distort the truth. About six to twelve crops grow on Singur's highly productive fields. The government has acquired 997.11 acres of land from poor farmers and handed over to a private company, taht is, Tata Motors. This is happening when Indian agriculture is in crisis, farm productivity is stagnating and declined and the country is facing acute shortage of food grains.
Singur land grabbing case (West Bengal) has resulted in a flare up between the local people and the Communist regime because of the insensitive and neo-capitalist mindset of the present leadership in West Bengal. The State government seems to be so much worried about big industries that it is playing with the lives of hundreds of farmers by snatching away their fertile lands in the name of industrialisation. Those who took to the streets in protest were brutally beaten up and put behind bars. Trinamul Congress President Ms Mamta Banerjee vociferously opposing the Tata Project in Singur was physically and mentally tortured by Communist parties in every possible way to force her to with-draw the agitation. But she is not the person to submit so easily. Her agitation drew the attention of every pro-farmer activist and leader in the country. The Singur issue hit national headlines when BJP President Shri Rajnath Singh decided to lend moral support to this agitation of farmers. He immediately rushed to Kolkata on the evening of December 3 after getting the news of three protesters having being killed in police firing. He met Sushree Mamta Banerjee and assured full support to her cause. Shri L. K. Advani and Smt. Sushma Swaraj also visited the agitating farmers and families of those killed to express our solidarity with them.

SEZs

One of the major UPA government scandals is the manner in which it has permitted mushrooming of over 400 proposed Special Economic Zones (SEZs) all over the country. By distorting a sound SEZ policy formulated by the NDA government, it has allowed many promoters to turn SEZs into the biggest land-grab rackets in the history of independent India.
This is evident from the fact that, under the UPA government's framework of SEZ, the promoters are allowed to retain as much as 65%-75% of the acquired land for non-processing purposes, that is, for purposes other than the industries and services for which the SEZ is sought to be established. All the attractive incentives available to the processing zone will also be available to the land under the much larger non-processing zone. The current legal framework of SEZs also creates number of disadvantages to industries and business in the Domestic Trading Area (DTA) with the distinct possibility of many of them turning sick.
Not surprisingly, many real estate companies, which have no track record in manufacturing or export business, have overnight become SEZ promoters. It is one of the worst-kept secrets of the UPA government that granting permission to establish SEZs has become a huge sources of corruption for the ruling party. This is a repeat of what happened in one of the biggest corruption scandals that rocked the Congress government in the early 1990s, when telecom licences were issued to all and sundry on considerations other than merit. Experts have already warned that many of the proposed SEZs will either not come up, or will not be successful. Never the less, they will have succeeded in dispossessing kisans, khetmazdoors (farm labour) and other allied rural workers of their sustaining and traditional sources of livelihood.

De-link Vote Bank While Dealing with Terror

Shri Yashwant Sinha
The Economic Times 12/9/2007
Modern Terrorism is a creation of the U.S. As part of its fight against the Soviets in Afghanistan, the U.S. had encouraged the wahabis in Saudi Arabia and involved Pakistan in the process as well. The terrorist mechanism began in Afghanisthan. The U.S. helped train the Taliban and sent them to Afghanisthan and Pakistan used the set up to send terrorists across to Jammu and Kashmir.
India can't depend on the world to fight terrorism. India must be self-reliant, strengthen its security forces, equip them well and take every step to improve the effectiveness of its defence.
UPA must delink vote bank while dealing with Terror. Don't link dealing with terror to vote bank.
We can not fight terrorism while linking it to internal politics. While we can not link religion to terrorism and accuse members of a religious community of acts of terrorism, we can't afford to be soft of terrorists simply because they belong to a certain religious community. We can't let vote Banks politics determine how we deal with terrorism. If we let vote bank politics take over, then we will never be able to beat terrorism.

Treat GITA as Rashtriya Dharma Shastra

Allahabad High Court
Hindustan Times 11/9/2007
The Allahabad High Court has expressed the view that it is the duty of the State to recognise the Bhagwad Gita as the Rashtriya Dharma Shastra, which inspired our national struggle for freedom and also all walks of life.
"As India has recognised national flag, national bird, national anthem and national flower, the Bhagwad Gita may also be considered as the Rashtriya Dharma Shastra."
"It is the duty of every citizen of India under Article 51A of the Constitution of India irrespective of caste, creed or religion to follow the 'dharma' propounded by the Bhagwad Gita," the High Court observed.
The view was expressed by Justice S.N. Srivastava while deciding on a write petition filed by priest Shyamal Ranjan Mukherjee of the Gopal Thakur Mandir of Varanasi, challenging the sale of temple properties.
The court also directed the state government, not to permit alienation of any property attached to any temple and other religious institutions (mutts, temples, specified endowments and samadhis) without prior permission of the district judge concerned.

Re-energise Rural INDIA

There was a sense that "India lives in her villages". Villages were considered as the backbone of our nation. The farmer was seen as carrying the nation's future on his shoulders. At least, that was the image. But, today, the situation is differen.
Rural India is in tears. Farm Income have collapsed. Hunger has grown very fast. Employment has collapsed. Non-farm employment has stagnated. Millions move towards towns and cities where, too, there are few jobs to be found. Many move towards a status that is neither farmer nor worker. A credit squeeze has pushed lakhs of farmers into bankruptcy. The Government tells us over 1,12,000 farmers have committed suicide since 1993. These are suicides driven by debt.
Large sections of rural India are starving. Rural masses have lost the purchasing power. Indian poverty is predominantly rural, where landless Labourers and casual workers are worst affected economic group. Schedule Castes and Tribes, women and children face more deprivation than others. Over large tracts of the country there is not enough work, not enough income, not enough food to eat and not enough water to drink for the rural population. So Rural India is in Acute distress.
Problem of Malnutrition :-
• A Man should eat at least 2400 Kilo Calorie food in a day according to National and International standard scale.
• Among the poorest section of the country 30 per cent of the people take 1600 Kilo Calorie food or less than it.
• In our country each year around 24 Lakh and 20 Thousand children of average age less than 5 years die because of malnutrition.
• In Maharashtra alone 1590 children died in 15 districts in just four months.
• More than 75% pregnant women, young women and less than 3 years of children are suffereing from malnutrition and mental and body weakness.
• An ADB study conducted by Administrative staff college of India, Hyderabad (1997) calculates malnutrition cost to India's GDP as 3-9% in 1996 (approximately $ 10-28 billion)
• The problem is no longer of absolute food shortage, but of bad distribution and poor governance.
• In a democratic country like India the problem of malnutrition is a matter of shame. The government should give priority in its agenda to reduce the problem of malnutrition.
Hunger and Poverty :-
Poverty is an extremely complex phenomenon, which manifests itself in a range of overlapping and interwoven economic, political and social deprivation. These include lack of assets, low income levels, hunger, poor health, insecurity, physical and psychological hardships, social exclusion, degradation and discrimination and political powerlessness and disarticulation. Therefore, policy makers should address not only the low-income or no-income and consumption aspects of poverty but also the complex social dimensions.
The Problem of unemployment :-
The Unemployment problem is also not tackled by the government effectively
Officially there are 3 crore educated unemployed youth from Rural areas registered with the employment exchanges across the country.
Highest Number of unemployed youth registered in :
West Bengal 46.74 Lakhs
Tamil Nadu 36.48 Lakhs
Maharashtra 33.66 Lakhs
Kerala 22.65 Lakhs
Karnataka 12.94 Lakhs
Assam 11.69 Lakhs
Haryana 6.57 Lakhs
Punjab 3.44 Lakhs
Delhi 7.39 Lakhs
Himachal Pradesh 5.82 Lakhs
Chandigarh 43000
Jammu & Kashmir 84000
This Problem of unemployment and under employment must be tackled on a war footing.
Total negligence of Basic Amenities :- There is a sharp contrast in Houses and Housing amenities in urban and rural areas. Housing in rural India is dominated by small huts, made of mud and clay. People have to fetch drinking water after travelling a minimum distance of 500 meters. Rural India still depends on kerosene for lighting. There is no bathroom and latrine facility for more than 80% of people in villages.
Exploitation of Poverty and Hunger :-
In Villages, due to poverty, Naxalite activities are growing
• Naxalite violence is continuing unabated. Available reports indicate that 125 districts, in 12 states, have now been affected by Naxalite violence in varying degrees and another 24 districts were being targeted by Naxal outfits.
• Till August this year, Naxalite violence has claimed 405 lives in 1140 incidents against 348 deaths in 1138 incidents in the corresponding period last year.
• CPI (ML) leader Kanu Sanyal proclaimed. "State power could be seized only through armed revolution. Guerilla war alone can expand the small bases of armed struggle to large extensive areas and develop the people's Army".
• Naxalites painted the streets of Calcutta with slogans such, as "China's chairman is our chairman".
• They had dumped Mahatama Gandhi literature in a heap and set fire to it in Jadavpore University.
• Naxals declared that "Annihilation of class enemies" is their goal.
• Who have given the Naxals the right to brand a particular person as class enemy ?
• The Naxals insurgency of three and half decades caused immense loss of life. About 2800 persons lost their lives so far. A large number had lost their limbs., about 10,000 children became orphaned.
• The Naxals blasted Govt. Buildings, Railway Stations, Bridges, Telephone Exchanges, Microwave Stations, Police Stations and burnt more than 1,000 RTC buses.
• The value of public and private property destroyed by various Naxal groups run into several crores.
• In each case of death by the extremists, the victims were severely beaten in the presence of the villagers to terrorise them and then ultimately the victim was killed.
• In one case, where a couple belonging to the backward class were returning home from their fields in the evening, the extremists caught hold both of them, severed the head of the husband and put it in the palms of his wife and his wife was made to parade in the village with the severed head of her husband in her palms.
• Who will stop these evil men and put an end to their gruesome inhuman violence and killings ?
Rural, Urban divide :-
Food grain, milk, vegetables, fruits etc, are produced in the villages and given to urban nourishment. So, the blood of the villages is the cement with which the urban edifice has been built. This development process has helped urban India to a greater extent than rural India. So it is high time, we must direct the development process to strengthen rural India and bridge the rural urban divide.
Farmers, who feed the country are committing suicide. It is an alarming situation in the country side. Poverty dominates the life of Indian farmers who produce food grains and feeds more than one billion people. It is the matter of national concern that the farmers of Maharashtra, Punjab, Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, West Bengal etc., are committing suicide. It is most saddening, unfortunate and horrifying. Majority of farmers are suffering due to burden of heavy debt. Farmers are suffering due to lack of availability of good seeds, electricity, water, lack of credit facility and marketing arrangement. There is absolute poverty, ignorance and lack of resources, which altogether have caused great pain and misery. It is a matter of shame, that the farmers, who feed the entire nation, are unable to feed their own children.
We all need to eat. The farmer in fields is thus making a sacrifice, in terms of opportunity, by remaining in it. We need to first recognise agriculture as an important field for public good and identify ourselves with the farmers.
A country wide movement is necessary to put an end to the suicide of farmers. Suicides are the result of debts, which were a consequence of the rising cost of production and falling prices. Something very fundamental is happening. The trends of growing dependence of formers in the suicide belt on hybrid and genetically modified seeds, which were costly and could not be saved.
In the year 1998, the world banks structural adjustment policies forced India to open up its seed sector to global corporations. The global corporations changed the input economy overnight. Farm saved seeds were replaced by corporate seeds which needed fertilizers and pesticides and could not be saved.
Corporate seeds :-
As seed saving is prevented by patents as well as by the engineering of seeds with non-renewable traits, seed has to be bought for every planting season by poor peasants. A free resource available on farms become a commodity which farmers were forced to buy every year. This increases poverty and leads to indebtedness. As debt increase and become unplayable, farmers are compelled to sell kidneys or even commit suicide. Seed saving gives farmers life. Seed monopolies rob farmers of life.
In the 1990s the worst sorrows of Farmers came to the surface. In the beginning it was believed that most of the suicides were happening among the cotton growers, especially those from Vidarbha. A look at the figures given out by the state Crime Records Bureau, indicate that it was not just the cotton farmer but farmers as a professional category were suffering, irrespective of their holding size. More over, it was not just the farmers from Vidarbha, but all over Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh, Kerala, Karnataka and Punjab, farmers suicide continues unabated.
UPA Government at the centre is anti Farmers and antipoor :-
The UPA government at the centre is, more bothered about registering economic growth rates to attract foreign investors, with the plight of the poor in India becoming a matter of secondary interest. Heartless central government is importing lakhs of tonnes of wheat from abroad.
Prime Minister Manmohan Singh is in the habit of forming committees for every serious issue, but when the report is ready, he usually becomes very reluctant to accept the recommendations. It is therefore important to exert pressure on the government to evolve a cohesive policy to check the spate of farmers suicides. The directionless government announces package after package. But the farmers are not happy with the 'relief packages' announced by the state and central government. they want the large issues driving the suicides are addressed. "Give us a price, not a package" is the demand of the farmers. They expect the government to actually implement the various money - lending Acts that already exists to prevent the alienation of the farmers land holding. Crop - insurance scheme must be made more farmer friendly, with lower premiam and less red-tape. Farmers should have quality agricultural inputs like seeds, fertilizers and pesticides. They should be prevented from cheating by unscrupulous suppliers of Industrial inputs for agriculture. Reliable agricultural advisories for farmers on form related practices are needed Better access to markets for agricultural produce to get higher rates for farmers produce will help them to a great extent. Better Education and Health facilities must be available in the villages itself. Since expenditure on these basic needs has been one of the most important financial drain in the village.
Small Farming is almost impossible :-
The direction of policy on farming - central to rural India is simple in its main idea to take agriculture out of the hands of farmers and place it firmly in the hands of large corporations. Every move, every policy, only pushes this idea further forward. We are witnessing the largest displacement in our history. It is not happening in a dam or a mining project. It is happening in agriculture. This is not being done with tanks and bulldozers. The Government make farming impossible for small holders. We have to stop this negative process.
Rejenuvation of Rural India is the need of the Hour :-
The entire country, its opinion makers, intelligentsia must identify themselves with sufferings of the poor and downtrodden. The nations prosperity is touching selected few of urban India while majority in the villages are the worst sufferers. There is an urgent need to quickly and radically change the living conditions of the disadvantaged in this country. Development of rural areas and rural people must be the primary concern of the economic planning and development process of the country. We must guarantee the wage employment, ensure food security, rural education, health, housing, roads, and drinking water. Better rural infrastructure can improve the economic status of the villages. The true cure to our problems is to create more jobs and better jobs. A report of the ministry of statistics and programme implementation which showed that BJP ruled states have faired better in implementing schemes like Sampoorna Gramin Rozgar Yojana, Village Electrification and assistance to SC/ST's and the weaker sections are really a matter of satisfaction.
V. Shanmuganathan